View Full Version : To spam or not to spam...
Zaragoth Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 3:17pm I was using irc... #sorcerers was the fairly nice place I entered.... I talked to someone.... I said iii i i a couple of times.... And now Iīm kinda down on lv 300-something... ouch... I just said a couple of ii i iīs, but it still counted as spamming... Dissapointed I am... Very... Shadow_Goddess were in there a few days earlier, doing the same thing... But I donīt think that she should get back to level 300-something because of that... Dissapointed I am.. again..... The rules are too strict I say. Dissapointed I am...
-----------------
Sorry, I donīt mean Shadow_Goddess. It was Shadow_Assassin. My wrong.
[This message has been edited by Zaragoth (edited August 22, 2001).]
AngelusDomini Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 3:39pm Such customer service complaints would best be addressed directly to the moderators. They graciously make their email addresses available at the top of the forum, left-hand side. I'm sure they will carefully consider your recommendations and offer you several options for resolution of this apparent misunderstanding.
AD
Lokken Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 3:42pm I would say it was more than just a couple of i's, and then you made a lot of downward typing too.
[EDIT]
Indeed AD, you're right. Any issues concerning problems with the moderators should be mailed to themselves.
[This message has been edited by Lokken (edited August 22, 2001).]
Zaragoth Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 3:54pm I still say that it isnīt right. I think that it should not matter as much as you people think it does! I donīt care about status.. I WAS talking to a guy, and we had nothing to talk about. So we talked about spamming. And I said i i i i ii i and such. Not too much though.
And when I entered, I wrote:
H
i
W
h
a
t
ī
s
u
p
?(And some other things.)
WHY does it MATTER? Itīs not like Iīm asking for an avatar because of the status thing! I just think that tīwould be cool to have my own. (I know that I must buy something, but I wonīt. I donīt want the avatar that badly.)
And the same thing goes on irc. I donīt care if you reset my levels, or word countings and such - Itīs just that itīs so wimpy! Why does it matter!?
I hope that you wonīt kick me or anything, Iīm just curious whatīs the big deal. thx// Jakob
Lokken Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 4:01pm The big deal is that it matters to some people. Some people find it fun to be on a list, and probably most of those people doesn't find it funny to be passed by a spammer on the list.
Mathetais Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 4:01pm !kick Zaragoth ;) :D
Honestly Z, I think you have to look at the big picture, and then realize that you might be getting penalized for the "greater good."
Personally, I refuse to post or chat in any other community because there is no control. People cut and paste, spam, edit huge Pokeman into their posts, etc. It makes me a little more insane than I really am.
Here at SP, there is a strict code of ethics. The moderators are quick to slice word counts when they see a reason. They try to be fair, but their biggest concern is to be even handed.
So, IMHO, your word count was cut, not because of a personal attack or because you were totally out of control, but so that we can maintain a precedent of good behavior in our community.
Given the choice between too much control and none at all, I would choose control. People will continue pushing the limits of behavior unless early action is taken.
BTW - I've tried some of those tricks myself and was humiliated by other people in the chat before it got out of hand. It seemed harmless, but I was ruining their experience.
Shadow_Goddess Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 4:04pm Zaragoth, put it this way, ppl don't like to read a whole page of hi what's up. And some ppl *do* care for their spot...such as me...but that's not the point.
BTW, thx for correcting your mistake on your first post.
Voltric Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 4:11pm Let me take this opertunity to vent about people that spam. I'd say that most folks on this board are fine. But in past months certain unnamed people have engaged in repeated spamming. You know who you are. Let's all try to be mature here. If you don't have anything worth while to say than don't say anything at all.
We encourage opinion and posters 'adding' something of value. Tal was right when he said that he didn't want to create the whole board ranking system because people would just post crap to get the post credit. Alas to a small degree this is true. When I see post saying "look I went up a level" I would to screen. Yes, you went up a level but I can see that without your spamming about it. Earning posts should be just that - earning them. You shouldn't be a high level of the community for simply typing "bump!" This only shows have shallow you are.
On a positive note I am glad that it isn't worse. I'd seen many boards that have numerous topics that are nothing but spam. We appear to only have 1 or 2 of those.
Tal and BTA do a good job of keeping with issue in check, but we can self regulate as well. Do your part for the quality of the community and contribute quality to SP not meaningless spam.
OK I feel better now. :) Thanks for putting up with me.
Zaragoth Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 6:11pm I can understand how you feel about spamming, but I just think that it was a little too.... much, to delete my levels. And thatīs that.
kevlar0101 Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 6:16pm I was foolish enough to copy paste the spam :D ;)
Blackthorne TA Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 6:20pm For someone who indicates that they "don't care about status", you are being rather verbose in your apathy.
Zaragoth Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 7:01pm What do you mean, BTA?? I donīt care about status. Iīm just wondering why itīs so strict.
Lokken Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 7:03pm If you wonder why it is so strict, I would advise to read through Mathetais post again, as it more or less perfectly explains why.
Zaragoth Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 7:10pm YES! I know! And I said that I understood! And then BTA started again! And I had to say something!
Taluntain Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 7:11pm Zaragoth, there are very few rules you have to live by in the chatroom, and "Ye Shall Not Spamme" is one of the most important ones. Same as with the avatars on the boards, status of the top talkers in the chatroom is earned. And posting crap to get a higher word count is considered cheating, on the boards and in the chatroom.
The only difference is, I can keep more control over the boards and taking 50 posts off someone who spams is usually enough to smarten them up. But in the chatroom, where 90% of the time I can't see what people do, stuff like that has to be punished that more strictly. ANYONE who is seen posting junk like you did gets their word count reset to zero. There were at least 20 people before you, and there will be many after you who will suffer the same fate, so don't pity yourself so much.
Remember, posting junk doesn't pay.
kevlar0101 Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 7:13pm :D unless its done with care and skill :D
;)
Zaragoth Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 7:17pm Argh! First of all, I didnīt know that the rules were different from the chatroom and the boards. I can understand that itīs more stricly, when you canīt see what happens from time to time.
AND I DON`T PITY MYSELF! :mad:
I do have the right to an oppinnion or a question, ainīt I? And I donīt consider this to be junk posting, since it was a simple question and a complaint!
thx// Zaragoth
[I told you in the chatroom that junk posting was what you did there, not here on the boards.] -Tal
[This message has been edited by Taluntain (edited August 22, 2001).]
Extremist Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 7:23pm Da hell, Voltric took my words!!! :mad: ;) :thumb up:
No matter, I'll spam some additional crap here...
I really don't care for levels of any kind as I said many times.
But there are some things about spamming that hurt my INT.
I like to read every single thread on these boards, but guys, I don't have time to read ALL spams. Maybe it is fun for you, but as I stated above, it hurts me. Ok, there are "spam topics" that ask to spam on, but spamming in serious threads... :rolleyes: :mad:
Spamming in chatroom is really lame. I like to see as many as possible previous text lines without scrolling up - and with your one word in a line I can't see it. I don't care if you think it is cool thing to see column texts.
Finally, I've never seen that mods leveldrained anyone just because they CAN. All leveldrained members got it because they deserved it. Including you Zaragoth.
But I agree that mods don't do the leveldraining job as I think it should be done - if I was them, I'd leveldrain much more persons here, including me.
Blackthorne TA Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 7:26pm Here is my point: If you do not care about your status in the chatroom, then why would it make any difference to you whether you lost your status or not? If it doesn't matter to you whether you lost your status or not, then why would it make any difference to you how easy or difficult it is for you to lose it?
My statement above is pointing out that you are expending quite a bit a verbiage on something you supposedly care nothing about.
[This message has been edited by Blackthorne TA (edited August 22, 2001).]
kevlar0101 Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 7:30pm so? anyone getting laid lately? :D
j/k ;) extremist is right we deserved it
[This message has been edited by kevlar0101 (edited August 22, 2001).]
Zaragoth Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 9:20pm I know that we deserved it Kevlar. Iīm just saying that itīs a bit too much to delete all the levels for a one-time spam.
I know that you all disagree with me, and you have a right to - But I also have a right to complain and say what I think.
This is NOT a thing Iīm doing to get you all mad at me, cuz I donīt want to do that. I just said what I thought was the thing to say, and I stand for what Iīm saying.
I donīt care for status nor levels, I just think that itīs an unneccessary thing to do.
But this is not my channel, and these are not my rules, and Iīm trying to follow them best I can, but as soon as I do one little thing I get banned or something. In this case, I got level drained - so to speak. thx// Zaragoth
Voltric Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 9:39pm Zaragoth, so you admit you spammed and you understand that spamming was the wrong thing to do. So what do you think you punishment should be for breaking the rules?
Avooch Dar Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 10:04pm i think that maybe we should just shame spammers on a list at the top of the page.(maybe spammer of the week?).
I think that i have been guilty of spamming occaisionaly although i try my best not too. However sometimes you just don't realise when you do it so maybe a less harsh punishment first time round like naming and shaming would be better.
PS. When i first got on the boards i spamed a bit and after a harsh e-mail from tal i did not intentionaly offend again! (scary bloke)
Lokken Wed, 22nd Aug '01, 10:40pm Before continuing, I think the spamming discussion should be split up, as the rules are quite different from the boards and the chatroom.
Still spamming isn't allowed in either case
herf Thu, 23rd Aug '01, 1:52am I agree with Zaragoth to a certain degree.
I belive the arguement he is making is that why remove his whole word-count for a first time minor offense.
I think his word count should be re-instated minus 1000 words or something similar.
And also, when a first offender is found out I think they should be warned, not immediately set to 0 in the chatroom.
Headbanger Thu, 23rd Aug '01, 2:00pm I'm not gonna say things about this. This is't my site, so I also don't set the rules. You just have to accept the rules or find a place where the rules are better. Of course I think he shouldn't be punished this way, just lower his words somewhat, for some these stats are very inmportant... :)
I also think it's better to give a wanring first (AND tell the consequences when they don't stop) So they know what happens then....
[This message has been edited by Headbanger (edited August 23, 2001).]
Lokken Thu, 23rd Aug '01, 2:12pm Same as with the avatars on the boards, status of the top talkers in the chatroom is earned. And posting crap to get a higher word count is considered cheating, on the boards and in the chatroom.
The only difference is, I can keep more control over the boards and taking 50 posts off someone who spams is usually enough to smarten them up. But in the chatroom, where 90% of the time I can't see what people do, stuff like that has to be punished that more strictly. ANYONE who is seen posting junk like you did gets their word count reset to zero.
- and that be the reason.
As a personal note:
People can easily spam when noone's there (physically), though it can't be known how often people do it, so that's why you get cut straight to zero. And frankly, I can't be bothered to read billion lines of text in the log every day to see if every single instance of a spam is considered a joke or not. And as of yet, there are still people who think their stats important, and those people would absolutely not think it fun to be overrun by a spammer.
[This message has been edited by Lokken (edited August 23, 2001).]
Zaragoth Thu, 23rd Aug '01, 7:47pm forget about it.. no use any way.
|
|