View Full Version : Kensai mispelled!
Goli Ironhead Sat, 11th Mar '06, 8:40pm Hello, after hours of investigating, i shall bring you this completely pointless knowledge:
Kensai is actually mispelling of kensei! As Wikipedia states, kenseis were warriors in japan who fought so flawlessy they were calle "sword saints". Miyamoto Musashi, himself, was one of the kensei, and surely the one worthy of the title. It also points out that kensei were mispelled as kensai or some similar way many times and still are. As the games point out, kensais are the ones taught to fight so deadly and fast that they're called "Sword saints"
So now i'm wondering, should a mod be made to correct this error? And could it be done, is kensai a hard-coded error?
Silverstar Sat, 11th Mar '06, 10:08pm I don'T think the name of a kit is unchangable.
I really understand your concern, and appreciate your hard work and hatred against this wrong. Though the real question is, unfourtunately'will people actually care about making a mod just for this?'
Then again, this is a fantasy game, not a realistic game, which claims to be original and true to every aspect of our world. Maybe these ferocious fighters are called 'kensais' in Faerun?
Truper Sat, 11th Mar '06, 10:25pm Heh - we could also add the fact that you've misspelled "mispelled" ;)
Gastong Sat, 11th Mar '06, 10:26pm nice
Silverstar Sat, 11th Mar '06, 10:30pm Guys, I don't think this was the point of this topic.
Goli Ironhead Sat, 11th Mar '06, 10:47pm And my english fails me ;)
Well, my point was that i'm pretty much a purist. Their description about kensei fits, so it think it's really just misspelling.
Perhaps no one cares, althought Silver seems to appreciate it, i just thought i should point it out.
Silverstar Sat, 11th Mar '06, 10:50pm Ofcourse I do appreciate your concern pal, and salute your effort to right this wrong.
BUT I really don't think anybody will care enough to make a mod for this, OR anybody will download that mod, for instance. So relax, and have fun! It is not the end of the world!
Goli Ironhead Sat, 11th Mar '06, 11:19pm I know that no one would make it or use it, as well as it won't be affecting anything.
Well, for vengeance I'm going to make kensai, named kensei and slay everything in the name of the correct spelling! That should teach 'em :)
Felinoid Sun, 12th Mar '06, 12:00am If you do make a fix for it, submit it to Baldurdash.
Prine Sun, 12th Mar '06, 3:45am If I ever bother to mod the Kensai kit, it'll be to change it into something else which actually belongs in the Faerun setting. I'm a purist too.
Ofelix Sun, 12th Mar '06, 6:20am Does the pronounciation differs also or just its spelling?
[ March 12, 2006, 20:11: Message edited by: Ofelix ]
Goli Ironhead Sun, 12th Mar '06, 7:36am Well, i'm not that expert with pronouncation, but it's not pronounced completely like English. Some of my friends claim Japanese is pronounced like Finnish, but there's some differences.
Perhaps someone else who knows more about pronouncing would help here?
Silvershield Sun, 12th Mar '06, 8:06am Maybe someone should write to someone at Bioware or something and ask them why they decided to spell it that particular way. I'd LOVE to hear the response! :D
Goli Ironhead Sun, 12th Mar '06, 10:31am Perhaps they would be confused and send me all their good games for free to keep me quiet! MUAAHAHA! :D
Seriously, they would probably just say that it was a mistake and they're sorry and so on.
CamDawg Sun, 12th Mar '06, 1:28pm Does the pronounciation differs also or just it's spelling?Yes. The 'sai' part is pronounced as rhyming with 'eye', whereas 'sei' would be pronounced like 'say'.
Goli Ironhead Sun, 12th Mar '06, 2:52pm Thanks, that's what I meant. At least it should be pronounced that way.
Silvershield Sun, 12th Mar '06, 4:15pm Umm, I'd rather prefer 'kensai' to 'kensei' because the 'eye' pronunciation just sounds better! Gives it that more 'asian' feel to the kit I reckon.
Goli Ironhead Sun, 12th Mar '06, 4:40pm "sai" is a close-range weapon, guess "sei" means saint or such, due to the fact "ken" means sword. So translation would perhaps be "Sword sai".
Silvershield Sun, 12th Mar '06, 4:49pm Oh. Well I guess the description of the Kensai was the 'sword saint' so maybe 'kenaei' would be a better name. Still, I'd prefer kensai, just for the way it's spelt and pronounced. It doesn't really occur to me how it's spelt :p
Goli Ironhead Sun, 12th Mar '06, 5:29pm Ken is pretty much the same, it's the "sai" or "sei" part that has the different spelling.
Taluntain Sun, 12th Mar '06, 7:51pm They've most likely spelled it kensai because it's also spelled like that in the AD&D source material. Source material misspellings usually carry over into RPGs. So there's really no point in "correcting" it in the game alone.
Harbourboy Sun, 12th Mar '06, 8:16pm Heh - we could also add the fact that you've misspelled "mispelled" Classic. Nonetheless, this is some excellent research.
Clixby Sun, 12th Mar '06, 8:54pm I think the difference in name is justified, as a kensei is just the name used for an extremely skilled warrior in Japanese lore, while the D&D Kensai is actually an avenue of training, and not an achieved title.
And by "hours of searching", I imagine you mean "typed Kensai into a Wikipedia search".
Felinoid Sun, 12th Mar '06, 10:35pm I think the difference in name is justified, as a kensei is just the name used for an extremely skilled warrior in Japanese lore, while the D&D Kensai is actually an avenue of training, and not an achieved title. I had a feeling it was oriental. Because I've never seen Kensei OR Kensai in any of the dozen supplements I have, but I never bothered to get Oriental Adventures. That said, it would be a disservice to the kit to name it wrong, but I imagine so many people are used to calling it Kensai after so many years of playing BG2 that I doubt it will/should be changed. Meh.
Baronius Mon, 13th Mar '06, 12:38am So now i'm wondering, should a mod be made to correct this error? And could it be done, is kensai a hard-coded error? It is in dialog.tlk, so correcting it is easy as pie. I don't know how it is done with WeiDU, as I don't know WeiDU too well, but it would need no more than a few minutes to write a C++ (or any other) program that fixes it.
Tony Tulipstomp Mon, 13th Mar '06, 8:43am Kensei is pronounced 'cane-say' for you nihongos!
So des yo!
|
|