Please comment on the game reviews thingy ( http://www.sorcerers.net/cgi-bin/ultimatebb.cgi?/topic/15/1457.html ) here.

This is a great idea! :thumb:

Can any type of game be reviewed?

Yep, same as with books. Anything goes.

Even pretty old games like Age of Empires II? I mean pretty much everyone knows of such famous games and has already played them by now.

So what? If someone wants to write a review of it, they're welcome to do so. I'm sure some people would still be interested in reading it.

A great idea, I might write a few for the games I have.

A question, if someone was in need of a certain review for a game, where would it be the correct place to request for one?

Well, The Playground, I guess... not that I think there would be much point in requesting reviews until we actually have a decent base of people who are willing to write them.

Still, we could post requests of reviews in that threat, considering that you are anyway duplicating the links given in your 2nd post. That way the topic would have more than a never ending number of duplicated links.

On second thought, requests can be posted in this thread; it's for commments, after all.

And I'm not duplicating anything. People posting links to their reviews there is a notice to me to update the main index. And since the notices are rarely formatted like the final index (compare the Booktalk reviews index), and they obviously can't be sorted in an alphabetical, ordered form like my main index is, they serve no other function but to notify me to insert them into the index.

It says "You have requested a topic that does not exist!" when I try to read the Call of Duty 2 review...

Ooooo Great Idea! I just posted my Dragon Quest 8 review :D !

Since the forum split, the non-RPG games reviews are in The Playground forum. Only the links in my indices are updated, so click on those.

great idea tal. i may post a few reviews for some that are imo underappreciated games