View Full Version : Historians Find "Missing" Lighthouse


Chandos the Red
Thu, 5th Jun '08, 6:36pm
You have to ask yourself why would the government move a lighthouse all the way across the Continetal United States? Here's the story:

WELLFLEET, Mass. - Local historians for decades thought the 30-foot tall lighthouse that once overlooked Wellfleet Harbor had been taken down and destroyed in 1925.

Turns out, it had just been moved to the California coast.

The fate of the cast-iron tower was uncovered last year by lighthouse researchers and reported by Colleen MacNeney in this month's edition of Lighthouse Digest.

MacNeney told the Cape Cod Times in Wednesday's edition it was her most exciting discovery.

Wellfleet historian Helen Purcell said the discovery of the lighthouse at Point Montara, 25 miles south of San Francisco, was a genuine shock.

MacNeney said she discovered correspondence that proved the lighthouse, first erected in 1881, had been moved by the Coast Guard from Wellfleet to Yerba Buena, Calif., and eventually to Point Montara.

There is no known documentation explaining how it was moved across the country, MacNeney said.



You wouldn't think you could find anything this interesting or "exciting" in "Lighthouse Digest." Here's the question I have for anyone who would know the answer: Wouldn't it just be cheaper to build a new one in California rather than haul a 30 foot lighthouse thousands of miles? I realize it could be taken apart and put back together. But I wonder if Halliburton has the government contract for lighthouses. :hmm:

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/24983428/

LKD
Thu, 5th Jun '08, 8:37pm
Is this really an Alley worthy topic? I mean, maybe lighthouses are a big deal to some people. I'd love to know the number of subscribers to that Lighthouse periodical.

What kind of a job is "lighthouse researcher"? The world is an odd place.

Are they gonna move it back across the country? Maybe they could make it a reality show.

T2Bruno
Fri, 6th Jun '08, 3:03am
In 1925 labor was cheap but getting funds allocated for the Coast Guard (or the equivalent) was extremely difficult.

Chandos the Red
Fri, 6th Jun '08, 6:09am
LKD - I wanted to place it in Whatnots, but the historical/political overtones caused me to place it here. If the mods wish to move it, I have absolutely no objections. My point was that there must have been a government contract somewhere in all this. While my "Halliburton" comment was just sarcasim, I'm sure that there have always been the Halli type companies that have made tons of cash off of government incompetence, especially in just such a "shocking" instance as this.

Much like you, LKD, I had no idea that lighthouses were such a big deal to some people; I mean, lighthouse "researchers?" Is that a real job? Or is it just something someone does who has too much time on his/her hands?

Gnarfflinger
Fri, 6th Jun '08, 6:30am
Is that a real job? Or is it just something someone does who has too much time on his/her hands?

I'd think the second, but if I can get paid for it, I'll give it a shot...

Ragusa
Fri, 6th Jun '08, 1:45pm
Also, it was a cast iron, that is more or less single piece, tower. That makes it mobile, say by ship or maybe by rail. It only needed a new foundation at the new site and be put up.

Chandos the Red
Fri, 6th Jun '08, 4:43pm
Even a house or a building can be moved by rail, but that is very expensive. I would think something that is cast iron and a single piece would be less mobile, rather than an object that is modular. But I'm not an engineer.

Ragusa
Sat, 7th Jun '08, 4:10pm
I would think that it is rather compact actually, after all it's just 30 feet high, and it is long-ish (which I draw from the noun 'tower' ;) ) which suggests that it ought to be relatively easy to transport by rail or ship. I guess that it would be similar in weight and dimensions to industrial machinery, or maybe a cruiser's gun barrel. I guesstimate the weight at some 20- tons.

T2Bruno
Sat, 7th Jun '08, 5:45pm
I believe they would ship it the same way the London Bridge was shipped to Arizona... completely disassembled and rebuilt at the new location.

Kitrax
Sun, 8th Jun '08, 2:03pm
Hmmm.... I clicked on this thread from the main page after seeing "Historians Find "Missing"...". I had just recently watched 'The Mummy Who Would Be King' (a PBS documentary on the missing/found mummy of Rameses I) so I thought this thread might be interesting... Instead, I find a thread on lighthouses. :skeptic:

I believe they would ship it the same way the London Bridge was shipped to Arizona... completely disassembled and rebuilt at the new location.
I agree with that. They probably cut it up in to 3 pieces...if you look at the picture, they could have removed the top section right below the walkway, then cut the tower in half at the visible seam. :rolling:

The Magister
Sun, 8th Jun '08, 6:48pm
I didn't even think there was much need for lighthouses these days, given the advancement of GPS and such. (that's a comment of the existence of a "Lighthouse Digest")

Anyway, I can see the American government of the time moving a large cast-iron cylinder to save money. Somehow it just seems right. :roll: