If you use any character and decide to pay the Shadow Theives 15,000 gp instead of helping Bodhi, can you just kill Gaelan Bayle and take the Shadow theif key?

I never tried killing Gaelan, but i think paying 15,000 gp will give you a key and trigger next chapter, so for the gamedesigh simplekill will get you nothing.

I think Gaelon is an onest guy and u shouldn't kil him. By the way that shadow thief avenger u can't kill could come and get u! If ya wanna kill Gaelon go to bodies side.

You shouldn't kill him because he is after all a good guy but if you want to be a badass than you can i am not sure though what will happen to the game after that though, it might go physcho just like when i Killed Imoen just as i exited the Fisrt dungeon and then when i got to the surface she was alive but her portrait was still there and it was gray. then i resorected her and the whole game got fully F***ed up. I used a Disintigrate spell to kill her bacuase i just wanted to see what would happen :)

you could but ill bet you anything the shadow thives wont be happy